Skip to main content

Metals, mining, and critical minerals

Sponsored Mining Equity Research

A mining project can have an attractive technical study and require substantially more capital than its owner can fund. AER builds mining research around both the asset and the listed company, so readers can follow the published technical evidence through production, cash flow, financing, and value per share.

On this page

Establish which technical evidence supports the model

We begin with the effective date, scope, and assumptions in the latest public technical disclosure. A historical resource estimate, scoping-level study, and feasibility study provide different levels of evidence. We review the level of technical work behind the production plan, the assumptions material to economics, and whether subsequent drilling, engineering, or permitting affects how the study should be read.

A mineral resource describes a concentration of material with reasonable prospects for eventual economic extraction under the relevant definitions. A mineral reserve is the economically mineable part of a measured or indicated resource after application of the relevant modifying factors. The CIM Definition Standards provide the framework incorporated into Canada’s NI 43-101 mineral project disclosure requirements. U.S. SEC registrants with material mining operations follow a distinct framework under Regulation S-K Subpart 1300.

We identify the economic and financial implications of published technical work. Resource and reserve estimates, and other technical determinations that require qualified-person involvement, remain the responsibility of the issuer and its qualified persons under the applicable framework. Our valuation distinguishes the disclosed base from optionality that still requires technical, permitting, or financing evidence.

Translate the mine plan into saleable production

A mine plan specifies when material is mined and processed. The production forecast depends on throughput, head grade, recovery, product quality, and the commercial terms that determine how much of the recovered product is payable. For a mine producing concentrate, the sales calculation may include payability, treatment and refining charges, and penalties. An early-stage critical minerals project may also need to demonstrate that its product meets the specification customers require.

Consider a simplified operation processing two million tonnes of ore at a 1% metal grade. That implies 20,000 tonnes of contained metal in the feed. At 85% recovery and 95% payability, the model would use 16,150 payable tonnes before other commercial adjustments. Variability in grade, recovery, downtime, and the product specification can change that figure across the mine life. A single steady-state assumption can obscure the lower throughput or different grade profile during commissioning.

We check whether the forecast is consistent with the disclosed schedule and stage of the asset. For an operating mine, reconciliation between planned and actual grades, recoveries, and costs can change the expected margins. For a development project, power, water, transport, permitting, and commissioning assumptions can influence when the modeled tonnage is commercially achievable.

Build costs and capital spending into the cash flow

The cash flow model starts with payable volumes, realized prices, and the cost of selling the product. We consider commodity and exchange-rate exposure, contract terms and deductions, and credits from by-products. The relevant price for a specialty material may depend on product form, grade, contract structure, and delivery point. We document the price assumptions and compare them with the ones in the technical study where relevant.

We separate initial construction and preproduction spending from sustaining capital and later development. Operating costs can include mining, processing, site overhead, freight, and treatment charges, depending on the asset. Input costs may vary with strip ratio, energy supply, reagent consumption, or labor availability. Royalties, taxes, working capital, and closure obligations belong in the cash flow schedule where applicable. They can materially change the value of projects with similar reported cash operating costs.

We assess the year-by-year funding profile as well as the total capital estimate. A longer construction period can increase cost, delay revenue, and extend the period over which interest accrues. A slower ramp can weaken cash flows just as the company begins servicing project debt. Modeling those interactions helps readers see where a project could require more liquidity than a standalone cost sensitivity suggests.

When comparing projects, we check the cost basis before drawing conclusions. Cash costs quoted after by-product credits can look lower than costs on a co-product basis. A cash-cost figure can also exclude expenditures needed to sustain production. Using consistent assumptions for credits, royalties, and sustaining capital makes the comparison more meaningful.

Reconcile project NAV with the listed company

Project net asset value discounts expected project cash flows under explicit assumptions about prices, production, costs, taxes, investment, and timing. The value reported in a technical study has its own assumptions and effective date. We explain material differences between that estimate and the assumptions used in AER research.

Equity valuation also depends on ownership, corporate cash and debt, overhead, royalties or streams, and the likely funding structure. We distinguish project debt, equity from the issuer, joint-venture contributions, and other capital arrangements. A stream can fund construction while assigning part of future production economics to the financing counterparty. An equity raise can fund a larger share of the project while increasing the number of shares entitled to the resulting value.

The bridge needs a consistent treatment of financing. A model that starts with unlevered project cash flows needs to reconcile value to corporate equity without double counting construction expenditure, debt, or funding proceeds. We show the effect of financing scenarios on per-share value separately where useful. That lets readers assess both the quality of the asset and the capital structure that could support its development.

Update the assumptions as the project advances

A sensitivity can isolate the effect of a lower metal price, higher capital cost, or change in discount rate. We also use combined cases where factors interact. For a development asset, weaker prices at the time of financing may affect both the project’s modeled margin and the availability or terms of capital. A scenario that incorporates each effect is more informative than treating them as unrelated.

Follow-up coverage tracks developments that alter the forecast. An updated resource can change the basis for future studies while leaving the current mine plan intact. A revised study can change scale, capital spending, or recoveries. Permits, offtake, partnership terms, construction progress, or early production results may each resolve different risks. We explain which assumptions have changed and how they carry through cash flows and shareholder value.

AER’s company-sponsored research program covers these developments within the company mandate. The guide to choosing a research provider explains how to assess a sample model and the provider’s approach to maintaining it.

Frequently asked questions

Can AER cover a project before a feasibility study?

Yes, where the public evidence can support substantive analysis. The work can examine technical progress, development steps, and financing while identifying the limits of a preliminary economic case.

How does AER handle a valuation that differs from a technical study?

We disclose the key differences in assumptions, such as prices, the valuation date, development timing, or financing. A project NAV and a company equity value also measure different interests and need to be reconciled.

Does a higher resource estimate always increase the base-case valuation?

The impact depends on how the additional material could enter the plan, the technical work supporting it, and the cost and timing of development. We may assess the new estimate as potential upside while retaining the published schedule in the base case.